I decided not to do a recap of the game this week simply because things weren’t pretty on the offensive side of the ball and I didn’t want to go one a 1,000 word tangent about it. Everyone in the country is talking about the play about the Cardinals QB’s so I will do the same.

Everyone, including myself, had Matt Leinart locked in to be the starter in Week One, but after his play so far in the preseason, no one can say that with 100 percent conviction. He hasn’t been down right bad like some in media have made him to be, but he hasn’t been very good either. For a guy that needed to prove that he was ready for the big time, he simply hasn’t done that yet, but there is still time to do so.
Leinart had four completions in six attempts on Monday night, but had only 28 yards and didn’t look comfortable in the pocket at times. He missed a deep throw to Steve Breaston that was at least five yards short of the receiver and the former USC signal caller was clearly upset after the play. I am far from an expert lip reader, but it looked as though he was upset with Breaston for not looking for the ball, but it wouldn’t have mattered with how poorly the ball was thrown.

With Leinart under center, the Cards had three consecutive three and outs. Surprisingly, Leinart didn’t come back out for the fourth drive of the game after playing so poorly to start things off. I am still not sure what Ken Whisenhunt’s thinking was behind, but Leinart clearly isn’t a happy camper. Then again, if he played at a higher level through these first two games than he wouldn’t be facing all of this scrutiny from the national media and fans.
Even though he threw for more than 100 yards, Derek Anderson wasn’t much better than Leinart was on Monday. He still continues to struggle with his accuracy on a consistent basis and his footwork is downright atrocious at times. You would think that the coaching staff is working on both of these things with him. Great accuracy and footwork are what separate the average quarterbacks from the great quarterbacks in this league.

With Leinart and DA struggling so far, Max Hall and John Skelton have probably been the most impressive QB’s on the roster. Sadly, they are both rookies. Hall got off to a bit of a rocky start in his first live NFL action on national television, but he managed to get the only touchdown for Arizona on the night with a beautiful throw to Max Komar on a 28-yard score in the middle of the fourth quarter.
Hall might not have the ideal height or size, but they said the same thing about Drew Brees and he turned out to be pretty good didn’t he? Hall is a winner, intelligent, works his butt off and still has good enough skills to be a starter in this league at some point. Skelton didn’t get to see the field on Monday, but expect to see plenty of him in the remaining two preseason games, especially in the fourth preseason game where all of the starters play very little minutes.

The question that remains on everyone’s mind is who will make the 53-man roster. No team keeps four quarterbacks, so one of these will probably have to go if the guy that loses out doesn’t go to the practice squad. Despite their poor play and the rumors that one of the two could be cut, Leinart and Anderson are guaranteed roster spots because of how much money is locked up to both players. Plus, it is hard to imagine Whisenhunt keeping two rookies and only one veteran on the roster at a position with all kinds of question marks right now. It is going to come down to Hall and Skelton.
The offensive struggles in the first two preseason games isn’t all on the quarterbacks. The offensive line hasn’t been very good in either pass or run protection. It doesn’t matter how good your quarterback are when they are getting hit on every play. Both Larry Fitzgerald and Early Doucet have been out with injuries as well, so Leinart and company have had less weapons to work with.
However, at the end of the day, the QB’s will always get the blame for the media and the fans. Everyone of them needs to play better if this team wants to return to the top of the NFC West this season. A good offensive showing in Chicago on Saturday would be a step in the right direction.
VN:F [1.4.6_730]
Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast)
Tags: Derek Anderson, Drew Brees, Early Doucet, John Skelton, Ken Whisenhunt, Larry Fitzgerald, Matt Leinart, Max Hall, Max Komar, Preseason, Steve Breaston